MSI GeForce RTX 5070 SHADOW vs XFX Radeon RX 9070 XT Mercury

MSI GeForce RTX 5070 SHADOW 12GB GDDR7 Black

MSI GeForce RTX 5070 SHADOW 12GB GDDR7 Black

MSI
85 Overall Score
vs
XFX Radeon RX 9070 XT Mercury 16GB GDDR6 Black

XFX Radeon RX 9070 XT Mercury 16GB GDDR6 Black

XFX
89 Overall Score

The MSI SHADOW G5070-12S3C is an RTX 5070 that wins on raw specs in more categories, but the XFX Mercury RX-97TRGBBB9 is a Radeon RX 9070 XT with 16GB of VRAM and a bigger memory bus that actually pulls ahead in 4K gaming and AI workloads. The XFX costs more and needs a beefier PSU, but owners rave about its thermals and price-to-performance. If you're at 1080p or building small form factor, the MSI makes a strong case; for 1440p/4K longevity, the XFX's extra VRAM is hard to ignore.

Choose MSI GeForce RTX if...

Grab the MSI if you're gaming at 1080p, building in a compact case, or upgrading from something like a GTX 1070 and want a quiet, efficient card that won't demand a PSU swap.

Choose XFX Radeon RX if...

Pick the XFX if you're pushing 1440p or 4K, care about future-proofing with 16GB of VRAM, and have the case space plus an 800W PSU to feed it.

Key Differences

  • VRAM is the big one: 12GB GDDR7 on the MSI vs 16GB GDDR6 on the XFX. The MSI's memory is faster (672 vs 644.6 GB/s bandwidth), but the XFX has more of it, which matters more at higher resolutions.
  • The XFX wins 4K gaming 83 vs 77 and AI/LLM workloads 67 vs 58, while the MSI takes 1080p 88 vs 82. So the XFX scales better where it counts for high-res and compute-heavy tasks.
  • Power draw is a real trade-off: the MSI sips 250W and only needs a 650W PSU, while the XFX pulls 304W and wants 800W. That's a potential PSU upgrade cost if you go team red.
  • Size matters for SFF builds: the MSI is 303mm long vs the XFX at 360mm. Owners of the XFX literally call it 'chonky' and note the included support bracket extender is too short.
  • Customer sentiment is higher for the XFX (92/100 vs 85/100), with owners praising thermals under 54°C and a 3-year warranty, while MSI users mention occasional frame generation artifacting and DLSS visual bugs.

What Buyers Say

MSI GeForce RTX 5070 SHADOW 12GB GDDR7 Black

85 out of 100 high confidence 52 reviews

The MSI RTX 5070 is widely praised for its compact size, quiet operation, and strong performance, especially as an upgrade from older cards like the GTX 1070 or RTX 3060. Users highlight its value at MSRP, good thermals, and effective cooling, though some note occasional artifacting with frame generation and the need for a proper power supply connection. Overall, it's seen as a solid mid-tier GPU for 1440p gaming and SFF builds.

Pros
  • Compact size for SFF builds
  • Quiet operation
  • Strong performance upgrade
  • Good value at MSRP
  • Effective cooling and thermals
Cons
  • Frame generation artifacting
  • Requires proper PSU connection
  • Large size in some models
  • Potential visual bugs with DLSS
👍 Performance 18
👍 Size 10
👍 Cooling 12
👍 Value for money 8
👍 Noise level 7
🤔 Frame generation 4

XFX Radeon RX 9070 XT Mercury 16GB GDDR6 Black

92 out of 100 low confidence 8 reviews

The XFX Mercury Radeon RX 9070 XT OC is highly praised for its excellent thermal performance, staying below 54°C under load, and its impressive out-of-the-box boost clock. Users highlight the great price-to-performance ratio, sleek design with customizable ARGB lighting, and the added benefit of a 3-year warranty. The only minor drawbacks mentioned are the large physical size ("chonky") and the short included support bracket extender.

Pros
  • Excellent thermal performance
  • Great price-to-performance ratio
  • Sleek design with ARGB lighting
  • 3-year warranty
  • Out-of-box boost clock
Cons
  • Large physical size
  • Short support bracket extender
👍 Thermal performance 3
👍 Price to performance 2
👍 Design and aesthetics 3
👍 Warranty 2
👍 Build quality 2
👎 Physical size 2

Scores

Budget
MSI
86
XFX
89
Gaming 1080p
MSI
88
XFX
82
Ray Tracing
MSI
84
XFX
86
Gaming 1440p
MSI
86
XFX
83
Gaming 4k
MSI
77
XFX
83
Content Creation
MSI
80
XFX
79
Workstation
MSI
68
XFX
73
Ai Llm
MSI
58
XFX
67

Specifications

MSI GeForce RTX 5070 SHADOWXFX Radeon RX 9070 XT Mercury
Chipset
GPU ChipsetGeForce RTX 5070Radeon RX 9070 XT
BrandNVIDIAAMD
ArchitectureBlackwellRDNA 4
Classconsumerconsumer
Process5★—
Memory
VRAM12 GB16 GB★
Memory TypeGDDR7★GDDR6
Memory Bus
192
256
Bandwidth
672
644.5999755859375
Compute
CUDA Cores
6,144
No data
Stream ProcessorsNo data
4,096
Tensor Cores
192
No data
RT Cores4864★
Base Clock
2,542
1,870
Boost Clock
2,542
3,100
FP16 TFLOPS30.8700008392334★—
FP32 TFLOPS30.8700008392334★—
Performance
PassMark G3D
28,703
26,910
GPU Compute
14,588
15,961
Power & Cooling
TDP250★304
Recommended PSU650★800
Power Connectors1 x 16-Pin3 x 8-Pin
CoolerTriple FanTriple Fan
Fans33
Connectivity
InterfacePCI Express 5.0PCI Express 5.0 x16
DisplayPort33
HDMI11
Max Displays44
Max Resolution7680 x 43207680 x 4320
Physical
Length303★360
Slot Width2.5★3.5
Form FactorFull HeightATX
Weight0.98 kg★1.81 kg
Features
Ray Tracing✓✓
UpscalingDLSS 4AMD FidelityFX Super Resolution 4
AV1 Encode✓✓
VR Ready✓✓
DirectX12 Ultimate12 Ultimate
RGB✗✓★

Pros & Cons

MSI GeForce RTX 5070 SHADOW 12GB GDDR7 Black

  • Strong connectivity (94th percentile)94th %ile
  • Strong thermal (92nd percentile)92nd %ile
  • Strong feature (89th percentile)89th %ile
  • Strong rt (83rd percentile)83rd %ile

XFX Radeon RX 9070 XT Mercury 16GB GDDR6 Black

  • Strong user sentiment (96th percentile)96th %ile
  • Strong feature (96th percentile)96th %ile
  • Strong connectivity (94th percentile)94th %ile
  • Strong social proof (93rd percentile)93rd %ile

Verdict

★ Winner: XFX Radeon RX 9070 XT Mercury

Scores 89 overall, wins 4 of 8 usage categories and 7 of 39 specs.

MSI GeForce RTX 5070 SHADOW Better at:

Gaming 1080pGaming 1440p

XFX Radeon RX 9070 XT Mercury Better at:

Ai LlmBudgetGaming 4kWorkstation