HP SmartMemory 32GB DDR4-2933 CL21 RDIMM Green
This 32GB DDR4-2933 RDIMM stands out with its dual-rank design and ECC error detection, which directly reduces server downtime and prevents unnecessary DIMM replacement. HPE qualifies and tests these modules for maximum signal integrity, delivering reliability above typical industry standards. It is best for IT administrators upgrading HPE ProLiant servers who need guaranteed compatibility and stability in mission-critical environments.
No current retailer price
Snapshot
The 30-Second Version
32GB of DDR4 ECC RDIMM with a 100th percentile feature ranking, but only 43rd percentile speed and 4th percentile affordability. It's built for HPE server reliability, not benchmark bragging rights. The CAD 2,634 price tag only makes sense if downtime costs you more than the RAM.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- 100th percentile feature ranking with ECC and XMP 2.0 support 100th
- 32GB capacity in a single module, above average at 71st percentile 71st
- Dual rank design improves memory bandwidth in server workloads
- HPE qualification testing on all server platforms for signal integrity
- Advanced error detection reduces DIMM replacement and downtime
Cons
- 2933 MT/s speed is only 43rd percentile, middle of the pack
- CL21 latency ranks 30th percentile, a weak spot
- Affordability is 4th percentile, one of the worst we've seen
- Laptop suitability score of 32.1, basically unusable there
- Social proof is thin at 20th percentile with only 4 reviews
The proof
Performance
Let's be honest about the numbers. 2933 MT/s with CL21 timings is not going to impress anyone who's seen DDR5 kits running at 6000+ MT/s. The speed percentile of 43rd means this is middle of the pack even among DDR4, and the latency ranking is a weak spot at the 30th percentile. The 21-21-21 timings are loose by today's standards, and the 1.2V operating voltage is standard for DDR4 but doesn't leave much headroom for overclocking.
However, the dual rank configuration does help with memory bandwidth in server workloads, and the registered ECC design means every bit of data gets checked for errors. That's not something you can measure in a quick benchmark, but it's the reason this module has a 100th percentile feature score. The heat spreader is a nice touch too, especially for 1U servers where airflow is tight. For a server running virtualization or a database, this is solid, if unspectacular, performance.
Specifications
Full Specifications
Memory
| Type | DDR4 |
| Form Factor | RDIMM |
| Total Capacity | 32768 |
| Modules | 1 |
| Per Module | 32768 |
| Pins | 288 |
| Rank | Dual Rank |
Performance
| Speed | 2933 |
| CAS Latency | 21 |
| Timings | 21-21-21 |
| Voltage | 1.2 |
Class
| ECC | Yes |
| Registered | Yes |
| OC Profile | Intel XMP 2.0 |
Features
| Heat Spreader | Yes |
vs Competition
Stacked against the competition, this HP module is in a different league entirely. The Kingston FURY Beast KF564C32BWEAK2-64 runs at 6400 MT/s, which makes the 2933 MT/s here look like it's standing still. The G.Skill Trident Z5 Royal and Corsair VENGEANCE RGB kits are also DDR5 monsters with speeds this module can't touch. Even the Crucial Pro Overclocking CP2K16G64C32U5B offers better speed at a lower price. But none of those have ECC, none are registered, and none are validated for HPE server platforms. The KLEVV CRAS V RGB is a gaming kit, not a server part. This HP module isn't competing with those on speed. It's competing on reliability and platform compatibility, which is a completely different game.
| Spec | HP SmartMemory | Kingston FURY Beast KF564C32BWEAK2-64 | G.Skill Trident Z5 Royal Series F5-6000J2636H32GX2-TR5NG | Corsair VENGEANCE RGB CMH64GX5M2Y6400C32 | Crucial Pro Overclocking CP2K16G64C32U5B | KLEVV CRAS V RGB KD5KGUD80-60A300G-BLACK |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Capacity | 32GB | 64GB | 64GB | 64GB | 32GB | 64GB |
| Kit | 1 x 32GB | 2 x 32GB | 2 x 32GB | 2 x 32GB | 2 x 16GB | 2 x 32GB |
| Memory Type | DDR4 | DDR5 | DDR5 | DDR5 | DDR5 | DDR5 |
| Speed Mts | 2933 | 6400 | 6000 | 6400 | 6400 | 6000 |
| Cas Latency | CL21 | CL32 | CL26 | CL32 | CL32 | CL30 |
| Form Factor | RDIMM | UDIMM | UDIMM | UDIMM | UDIMM | UDIMM |
| Ecc | true | false | false | false | false | false |
| Compare | Compare | Compare | Compare | Compare |
| Product | Speed | Feature | Latency | Capacity | Social Proof | Affordability |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HP SmartMemory | 43.4 | 99.8 | 29.6 | 70.7 | 20.4 | 4.3 |
| Kingston FURY Beast KF564C32BWEAK2-64 Compare | 94.8 | 89.6 | 87.6 | 89.8 | 92.3 | 7.6 |
| G.Skill Trident Z5 Royal Series F5-6000J2636H32GX2-TR5NG Compare | 87.5 | 89.6 | 99.1 | 89.8 | 74.3 | 3.7 |
| Corsair VENGEANCE RGB CMH64GX5M2Y6400C32 Compare | 94.8 | 89.6 | 87.6 | 89.8 | 97.8 | 6.8 |
| Crucial Pro Overclocking CP2K16G64C32U5B Compare | 94.8 | 74.8 | 87.6 | 70.7 | 85.7 | 27.4 |
| KLEVV CRAS V RGB KD5KGUD80-60A300G-BLACK Compare | 87.5 | 89.6 | 87.6 | 89.8 | 85.7 | 9.4 |
Price
Value & Pricing
Here's where things get painful. The affordability ranking is 4th percentile, which means this is one of the most expensive DDR4 modules in our database. The only price we have is CAD 2,634 from a single Canadian listing, and that's a lot of money for 32GB of DDR4 in 2024. You're paying for the HPE badge, the enterprise validation, and the reliability guarantees. For a business running critical infrastructure, that premium might be worth it. For anyone else, you can get faster consumer DDR4 for a fraction of the price. The value proposition only makes sense if downtime costs you more than the RAM does.
Read more
Overview
The HP SmartMemory P00924-B21 is a 32GB DDR4 RDIMM that sits in a weird spot. It's got a 100th percentile feature ranking, which sounds great until you realize that means it's loaded with enterprise extras like ECC and XMP 2.0, not that it's fast. The 2933 MT/s speed lands at the 43rd percentile, and the CL21 latency is even worse at the 30th percentile. This is server memory, not gaming RAM, and the scores reflect that: 67.4 for servers, 48.6 for workstations, and a rough 32.1 for laptops.
But here's the thing. This module isn't trying to win benchmark races. It's built for reliability in HPE server platforms, with advanced error detection and signal integrity testing that consumer RAM just doesn't get. The dual rank design and registered ECC mean it's meant to sit in a rack and run for years without a hiccup. If that's your use case, the unimpressive speed numbers matter a lot less than the fact that this thing won't randomly corrupt your database at 3 AM.
Common Questions
Q: Is this memory compatible with non-HP servers?
While this is an HPE SmartMemory module, the DDR4 RDIMM standard means it should work in most servers that support registered ECC DDR4. However, the XMP 2.0 profile and HPE-specific optimizations are designed for HPE platforms. The 100th percentile feature ranking reflects these enterprise extras, but you'll get the most benefit in an HPE server where the validation testing applies.
Q: Why is this 32GB module so expensive compared to consumer DDR4?
The affordability ranking is 4th percentile, meaning this is one of the most expensive DDR4 modules in our database. You're paying for ECC, registered design, HPE validation testing, and enterprise-grade reliability features. The advanced error detection and signal integrity testing add cost that consumer RAM doesn't have. At CAD 2,634, it's priced for businesses where server downtime is more expensive than the memory itself.
Q: Can I use this in a gaming PC or workstation?
Technically yes, if your motherboard supports registered ECC DDR4, but it's not a great idea. The workstation score is only 48.6 out of 100, and the 2933 MT/s speed with CL21 latency ranks 43rd and 30th percentile respectively. You'd be paying a huge premium for ECC features you don't need while getting slower performance than consumer DDR4 kits that cost much less.
Who Should Skip This
Skip this if you're not running an HPE server. The laptop score of 32.1 makes it basically useless for portable machines, and the workstation score of 48.6 suggests there are much better options for desktop use. The 43rd percentile speed and 30th percentile latency mean you're not getting performance bragging rights. And at 4th percentile affordability with a CAD 2,634 price tag, you're paying enterprise prices for specs that consumer RAM beats at a third of the cost. If you don't need ECC and HPE validation, you don't need this module.
Verdict
The HP SmartMemory P00924-B21 is a purpose-built tool, not a general-purpose upgrade. If you're running an HPE server and need ECC memory that won't cause problems, this is a solid choice with a 100th percentile feature set and the reliability testing to back it up. The 67.4 server score confirms it's best in that role. But if you're building a workstation or gaming rig, the 48.6 workstation score and 43rd percentile speed should send you elsewhere. The 4th percentile affordability ranking means you're paying a serious premium for that enterprise validation. Buy it if your server demands it, skip it if you just want fast RAM.
Usage Scores
- Overall43.9
- Budget38.1
- Gaming37.5
- Laptop32.1
- Server67.4
- Workstation48.6